Downsizing in Hermitage: Your Options for Staying Close to Home
If you want to downsize but stay in Hermitage, you have more options than most people expect: a one-level ranch in an established neighborhood, a 55+ community like Parkhaven, a townhome or condo where the HOA handles the outside, or staying put and adapting the house you have. The right choice usually comes down to three things: how much upkeep you still want, whether you need everything on one floor, and how the numbers work once you account for selling your current home, moving costs, HOA dues and property taxes. You don't have to leave the neighborhood, the church or the friends you've had for decades to make your life easier.
I've lived and worked on this side of Nashville my whole career, and downsizing conversations are some of the most common ones I have. Most people aren't trying to move far. They want less house, less yard and fewer stairs, and they want to keep shopping at the same grocery store and seeing the same neighbors. Here's how I walk people through it, including the trade-offs.
Start with what you actually want to stop doing
Before we look at a single home, I ask people to finish one sentence: "I'm tired of..." The answers are usually specific. Mowing an acre. Cleaning gutters. Climbing stairs to the bedroom. Heating rooms nobody uses. Paying for a house built for a family of five when it's just two of you now.
That list does more to narrow your search than a price range does. If stairs are the problem, a two-story townhome isn't a fix. If the yard is the problem, a smaller lot might be enough and you don't need an HOA. If you want to lock the door and travel for a month, maintenance-free living starts to make a lot of sense.
Option 1: A smaller one-level ranch in an established neighborhood
A lot of Hermitage was built with single-level brick ranches, and they're still one of the easiest ways to downsize without changing your life much. You keep a little yard, you don't pay HOA dues in most older neighborhoods, and you're often a few minutes from where you live now.
The trade-off is age. Many of these homes are decades old, so you're buying the roof, HVAC, water heater and windows along with the floor plan. A smaller older home can still need real money in the first few years. I wrote a separate guide on what to check before you make an offer on an older ranch in Donelson or Hermitage that's worth reading before you shop.
Also look for things that matter more as the years go by: a no-step or one-step entry, a walk-in shower or room to add one, wider hallways, and a laundry on the main level.
Option 2: A 55+ community
Hermitage has a newer age-restricted option in Parkhaven. Dream Finders Homes markets its section, Reverie at Parkhaven, as a gated 55+ community with a clubhouse, a fitness center, pickleball and bocce courts, and fire pits and gathering areas. Most plans there are one story, but not all of them, so ask before you tour.
The upside of a 55+ community is a built-in social life and homes designed for this stage, often with the primary bedroom on the main floor. The things to look at closely:
- HOA dues and what they cover. Lawn care, exterior maintenance, amenities and the gate all show up in the monthly fee. Ask for the current budget and the rules, not just the brochure.
- New construction pricing versus your budget. New homes in a community like this can cost as much as, or more than, the home you're selling. Downsizing in square footage doesn't always mean downsizing in price.
- Resale rules. Age restrictions limit who can buy from you later. That's part of the appeal, and it's also something to understand going in.
Option 3: A townhome or condo with exterior maintenance
If the goal is "I never want to think about the roof again," a townhome or condo with an HOA that covers the exterior can be a good fit. These usually cost less than a new home in a 55+ community, and many are close to Old Hickory Boulevard and Lebanon Pike.
Read the HOA documents before you fall in love. Some associations cover roofs and siding, others only cover the lawn. Ask about the reserve fund, any planned special assessments and rental rules. And check the floor plan: plenty of townhomes put every bedroom upstairs, which defeats the purpose if stairs are why you're moving.
Option 4: Stay where you are and make the house work
Sometimes the honest answer is not to move. If your home is paid off, your property taxes are low and the main issue is a bathroom or a step at the front door, it can make more sense to remodel one bathroom, add grab bars and a ramp, and hire out the yard work.
This is also where Davidson County's property tax programs matter. The Metro Trustee offers a Tax Freeze for homeowners 65 and older under an income limit, and a separate Tax Relief program. The income limits change every year, so check the Trustee's site or call the office at 615-862-6330 for the current numbers. Applications open each fall and run through April 5, and current members have to send in their voucher every year. If you're enrolled now, call the Trustee's office before you buy anything and ask how a move would affect you, because a freeze tied to your current home is worth factoring into the math.
The money side of downsizing
Downsizing is usually a sell-and-buy at the same time, and the order matters. Some people sell first and rent or stay with family for a short stretch. Others buy first using their equity or a bridge loan. Some write offers contingent on selling their current home, which works better in some markets than others. We'd talk through which fits your situation and how comfortable you are with each one.
A few numbers to get in front of you early:
- What your current home will really sell for. Long-time owners in Hermitage often have significant equity. Online estimates tend to miss both the original kitchen and the meticulous care. Here's how I figure out what a Nashville home is really worth.
- Your total monthly cost in the new place, including HOA dues, insurance and taxes, not just the mortgage if you have one.
- Taxes on the sale. Federal rules let many owners exclude a large part of the gain on a primary residence, but there are limits. Talk with your CPA before you list.
Don't underestimate the move itself
Getting through thirty years of belongings is often harder than the real estate. Start with the rooms you don't use, decide what your kids actually want (ask them, don't assume), and plan for an estate sale or donation pickup for the rest. If you're helping a parent through this, my post on helping aging parents move in Nashville covers the family side in more detail.
Let's look at your options together
Downsizing doesn't have to mean leaving Hermitage, and it doesn't have to happen on anyone else's timeline. If you'd like to talk through what your home might sell for and what you could move into nearby, I'm glad to sit down with you. No pressure and no obligation, just a clear picture of your choices. Call or text me at 615-260-0521.
Categories
Recent Posts









